The short answer
Choose Proton Drive if you want encrypted storage on every device, including iPhone, Android and Windows, at a lower price per terabyte. Choose CloudRoomy if you work on a Mac that keeps running out of disk: both encrypt every file end to end, but CloudRoomy fetches only the parts an app reads and keeps files at zero bytes on disk, while Proton Drive downloads a file when you open it and keeps it on the Mac.
Free for 30 days with 50 GB, no card needed. Then plans from €7.99 a month, or €49 once with your own storage. See plans and prices.
How each one handles files on your Mac
Proton Drive downloads a file when you open it and keeps it until you free the space. CloudRoomy fetches only the 1 MB pieces an app reads, so a file bigger than your free space still opens.
Proton Drive's Mac app puts a Drive folder under Locations in the Finder sidebar, and it needs macOS 13 or later. Files can be online-only placeholders that don't store their contents on the Mac. Proton's help says: "When you open a file, Proton Drive downloads it to your device so you can view or edit it", and the file "will remain on your device" until you Control-click it and choose Online Only (Free Up Space), or macOS reclaims the space.
CloudRoomy is a drive of its own in the Finder sidebar. Files show their full size at zero bytes on disk, and only the pieces an app actually reads are fetched. In our test on 12 November 2026, a 9.9 GB file was copied in and read back intact on a Mac with 8.9 GB free. Recent pieces stay on the Mac up to a limit you choose (1 to 50 GB), and you can keep chosen folders on the Mac for use offline. More on how files open on demand.
Encryption
Both encrypt your files on your device before they are uploaded, on every plan. Neither company can read them.
Proton says your files are "end-to-end encrypted, meaning your files are encrypted on your device before they're uploaded to our servers", and that includes the free plan. CloudRoomy seals file contents and file and folder names with AES-256-GCM on your Mac, and the key stays in your Macs' Keychain. A new Mac gets it only when you approve it from a Mac you have, or with your recovery code. We can't reset that code, so keep it safe. Read how CloudRoomy encrypts your files.
Prices
Proton Drive costs less, and it has a free plan. CloudRoomy's price buys files that open by the part, Free Up Space and app offloading, and the own-storage licence is €49 once.
| Plan | Storage | Billed monthly |
|---|---|---|
| CloudRoomy trial | 50 GB | Free for 30 days, no card |
| CloudRoomy | 500 GB | €7.99 a month |
| CloudRoomy | 1 TB | €14.99 a month |
| CloudRoomy | 2 TB | €29.99 a month |
| Proton Free | 5 GB | Free |
| Proton Drive Plus | 200 GB | €4.99 a month |
| Proton Unlimited (with VPN, Mail and more) | 500 GB | €12.99 a month |
| Proton Duo (2 people) | 2 TB | €19.99 a month |
When we checked, Proton was running Black Friday prices on yearly billing: Drive Plus at €2.49 a month, Unlimited at €6.49 and Duo at €14.99. CloudRoomy's yearly plans cost ten months' price. CloudRoomy's prices are the same numbers in US dollars outside the EU, tax included, and every plan has every feature. With your own S3-compatible bucket, CloudRoomy is a one-time €49 or $49, and your provider bills you for the storage. Read how your own storage works.
Side by side
| CloudRoomy | Proton Drive | |
|---|---|---|
| Opening a cloud-only file | Fetches only the parts in use | Downloads the file, which then stays on the Mac |
| Freeing the space again | Automatic, within a limit you choose | Online Only (Free Up Space), by hand, or when macOS reclaims it |
| End-to-end encryption | Every plan and the trial | Every plan, including Free |
| Clears space beyond your files | Free Up Space and app offloading | No |
| Your own storage | Any S3-compatible bucket, €49 once | No |
| Runs on | Macs with Apple silicon and macOS 26.2 or later; your drive in a browser | macOS 13 or later, Windows, iPhone, Android and the web |
| Free plan | No. A 30-day trial with 50 GB. | 5 GB |
| Earlier versions of a file | One earlier copy an hour, kept in Recently Deleted | Drive Plus: 10 years to recover previous versions |
Good to know before you switch
Proton Drive fits better if you need your files on a phone or a Windows PC, want a free plan, or already use Proton Mail or Proton VPN. A good setup can be both: Proton for files you need everywhere, CloudRoomy for the big folders on your Mac.
- CloudRoomy is a Mac app for Apple silicon and macOS 26.2 or later. In a browser you can browse, preview, download and upload, but not rename, move or delete.
- CloudRoomy is new: it launched in November 2026. Proton Drive has been on the Mac since 2023.
- A file that is only in the cloud needs a connection to open, and changing part of one needs room on the Mac for the whole file until it uploads.
- There is no free plan. When a trial or plan ends the drive turns read-only, and files are kept 30 days after a trial or 90 days after a paid plan before they are deleted.
How to move from Proton Drive to CloudRoomy
- Start the trial or pick a plan bigger than what you are moving. Get Info on a folder in Finder shows its size.
- Copy, don't move. Open your Proton Drive folder in Finder, select a folder, choose Edit › Copy, then open your CloudRoomy drive and choose Edit › Paste.
- Work in batches on a full Mac. Online-only files download before they can be copied. Copy one folder, let CloudRoomy upload it, then choose Online Only (Free Up Space) on it in Proton Drive before the next.
- Check the copies: compare item counts and sizes, and open a few files.
Questions people ask
Is there a Proton Drive alternative for Mac that keeps files off the disk?
Yes. CloudRoomy is end-to-end encrypted like Proton Drive, but it fetches only the parts of a file an app reads and keeps files at zero bytes on disk. Proton says an opened file downloads to your device and remains there until you choose Online Only (Free Up Space) or macOS reclaims the space.
Is CloudRoomy as private as Proton Drive?
Both encrypt files on your device before upload, so neither company can read them. CloudRoomy also encrypts file and folder names with AES-256-GCM, and the key stays in your Macs' Keychain.
Is CloudRoomy cheaper than Proton Drive?
No. Proton Drive has a free 5 GB plan and costs less per terabyte: Proton Duo with 2 TB is €19.99 a month against €29.99 on CloudRoomy. With your own S3 storage, CloudRoomy costs €49 once.
Does CloudRoomy work on iPhone or Windows like Proton Drive?
No. CloudRoomy is a Mac app for Apple silicon and macOS 26.2 or later, and your drive also opens in a browser. Proton Drive has apps for Mac, Windows, iPhone and Android.
Try it on your own Mac
Install CloudRoomy, copy your biggest folder onto the drive, and open a file that is bigger than your free space. The trial gives you 50 GB for 30 days with every feature and no card.
Sources: Proton, Proton Drive pricing; On-demand sync on Proton Drive for macOS; How to use Proton Drive on macOS; Download Proton Drive; Proton Drive for Mac launch. Checked 18 November 2026. CloudRoomy facts come from our own app; we ran the 9.9 GB test on 12 November 2026.